How to Bet MLB Awards In-Season

Betting on the MVP, Cy Young, and Rookie of the Year races is one of the most exciting ways to stay engaged throughout the MLB season. While most of the attention goes to preseason lines, sharp bettors know these markets are updated daily – which means betting MLB Awards in-season presents tons of opportunity.

Whether you’re eyeing a breakout rookie, a surging ace, or a bounce-back MVP candidate, here’s what to watch for and how to find value.

Watch for Odds Movement

Award futures shift every single day. A hot streak, a minor slump, or a short-term injury can cause significant swings in price – even if it doesn’t really affect a player’s overall outlook.

That creates value. Sportsbooks sometimes overreact. If you liked a player before a hitless series or a minor injury, you might now be getting a better number for the same bet.

In a 162-game season, short-term slumps shouldn’t outweigh long-term upside – especially early on. The key is zooming out while everyone else is zoomed in.

Trust Underlying Metrics

Small sample sizes can be misleading. A player might be hot – but is it sustainable?

That’s where advanced stats come in. Sites like FanGraphs and Baseball Savant provide deeper insights into how players are really performing, even if the box scores don’t show it yet.

For pitchers:

xERA
Whiff rate
Stuff+, Pitching+, Location+
Velocity trends

For hitters:

Hard-hit rate
Plate discipline (chase rate, walk rate)
Launch angle, xwOBA

These metrics help identify candidates for positive regression – a key ingredient for buying low in awards markets.

Look at the Schedule

Sometimes, value comes down to timing. Is a hitter heading to Coors Field? Is a pitcher facing three bottom-tier lineups in a row?

You don’t need to wait for big shifts – sometimes you can anticipate them. A three-game heater in a hitter-friendly park can move MVP odds fast. Same with a starter stringing together back-to-back gems against weak offenses.

Looking ahead at matchups can give you an edge before the market reacts.

Embrace the Longshots

Favorites drop out. Every year.

Injuries, slumps, and surprise breakouts create chaos in awards markets. And in the early months, when the sample sizes are small, the odds can be wildly misaligned with true talent and opportunity.

This is especially true with Rookie of the Year, where timing and opportunity are everything. Top prospects might not debut until May. Others might catch fire unexpectedly. There’s value in betting talent before it shows up on the stat sheet.

The same goes for MVP and Cy Young. The betting favorite rarely runs away with it from wire to wire. Don’t ignore the middle tier, or even the deep cuts, especially early in the season.

Study the Past

Want to know how a rookie can win despite a late start? Curious how many MVPs made their run in July, not April?

Look back.

Studying previous seasons helps you understand how voters think, how late a breakout can happen, and what kind of performance really moves the market. You’ll see patterns like how many recent ROY winners started in the minors, or how many Cy Young contenders finished strong after a slow April.

Understanding historical market movement can also help you decide when to buy in. Odds tend to stabilize by midseason – but they don’t stop shifting.

Final Thoughts

In-season award betting is all about timing, context, and staying informed. Look beyond the surface stats. Anticipate performance shifts. Know the narrative arcs. And when the moment is right, pull the trigger – even if the rest of the market hasn’t caught up yet.

If you liked this article, you may enjoy these too:

Top 10 Starting Pitchers in MLB

Straight Division Betting Tips

Ranking 10 Best MLB Players for 2025

10 Best MLB Pitcher Props in 2025

3 Longshot Bets for AL and NL Cy Young Winners

2025 Ten Best Home Run Season Prop Bets

3 Value Longshot Bets for AL and NL MVP

5 Key Tips for Betting on MLB Player Props

10 Key Storylines to Follow When Betting on the 2025 MLB Season

Seven Best Win Total Bets for the 2025 MLB Season

Guide to Betting on MLB Win Totals