The process of an idea becoming a Fringe article is not nearly as drawn out or deliberate as some people might think. Most of the time, an idea flashes into existence for a split second, just long enough to be scribbled down before life moves on.
Those ideas live in a running Google Doc. Some are a sentence or a half-thought. Some are nothing more than a name or a historical footnote with a question mark next to it. The hope, of course, is that one day an idea jumps off the page and grows into a full Fringe article. But more often than not, that never happens.
Most ideas stay exactly where they started. They linger, age, and get passed over week after week. Not because they are bad ideas, but because they lack something essential. A clean narrative. A satisfying arc. A payoff that justifies the space.
This week, instead of forcing one of those ideas into something it was never meant to be, we’re doing something different. We’re letting a few of them stand on their own.
These are stories, facts, and ideas that were compelling enough to write down, interesting enough to remember, but ultimately didn’t quite have what it took to become full-fledged Fringe articles. They may not have been ready for prime time, but they’re still worth your time.
Here are a few of the best ones.
1. David Cutcliffe, Eli Manning, and the Ultimate Recruiting Pitch
In the NIL era, we’ve grown accustomed to schools rolling out every possible incentive to land elite recruits. Lavish facilities, branding campaigns, collectives, and yes, sometimes things that toe the line of what’s supposed to be allowed.
Even before NIL, recruiting was rarely subtle. Helicopter rides to high school games. Boosters suddenly becoming very generous. Parents finding unexpected upgrades in their driveway. None of this is new.
But there may never have been a more powerful recruiting pitch than simply letting a recruit pick the head coach.
David Cutcliffe was Peyton Manning’s offensive coordinator at Tennessee and one of the primary reasons Peyton chose the Volunteers over Ole Miss, his father Archie’s alma mater. For Ole Miss, that decision was brutal. Archie Manning is not just a former quarterback in Oxford. He is royalty. The speed limit on campus is literally his jersey number. Watching his son choose a conference rival instead was embarrassing in a way that lingered.
A few years later, Ole Miss was given a rare chance at redemption. Another Manning was coming through the pipeline, and this one was headed for a recruiting decision of his own.
When Ole Miss needed a new head coach just months before Eli Manning was set to choose a school, the solution became obvious. Hire the man Eli already trusted. Hire David Cutcliffe.
Despite Tennessee’s success during his time as offensive coordinator, Cutcliffe had surprisingly little head coaching traction at the time. In fact, before Ole Miss made its move, he was being seriously considered for the Middle Tennessee State job. That tells you everything about how differently he was viewed then compared to now.
Ole Miss hired Cutcliffe, and Eli Manning followed. Mission accomplished.
The plan worked. The Cutcliffe era was productive. Ole Miss won games. Eli developed into the player everyone hoped he would be. And yet, in one of the more quietly ironic twists in SEC history, Cutcliffe was fired shortly after Eli left for the NFL.
At the time of his dismissal, Cutcliffe ranked third all-time in wins among Ole Miss head coaches.
The ultimate recruiting pitch worked perfectly. It just didn’t last.
2. Mario Cristobal Was Fired by FIU
Mario Cristobal is widely regarded as one of the top coaches in college football today. He recruits at an elite level, commands respect nationally, and has positioned himself as a major figure in the modern sport.
Which makes this fact easy to forget: Mario Cristobal was fired by FIU.
After a solid playing career at Miami and time as an assistant, Cristobal landed his first head coaching job at Florida International. The program was barely off the ground, coming off an 0-12 season in just its third year of existence.
Cristobal didn’t just stabilize the program. He built it. By his fourth season, FIU won a bowl game, a remarkable accomplishment given where the program started. For a brief moment, FIU looked like a rising Group of Five success story.
Then things went sideways.
In Cristobal’s sixth season, FIU regressed badly, finishing 3-9. Despite what he had already built, FIU pulled the plug. The firing was met with immediate backlash, especially locally. Many thought the school had made a massive mistake.
They were probably right.
Cristobal landed on his feet almost instantly, becoming Nick Saban’s assistant head coach, offensive line coach, and recruiting coordinator at Alabama roughly a month later. That stop became the launching pad for everything that followed.
For years, many assumed Cristobal had willingly left FIU for Tuscaloosa. The reality is far messier.
There’s always been quiet speculation about whether FIU’s leadership was uneasy with Cristobal’s open admiration for Miami, the program that loomed over FIU both geographically and culturally. As long as FIU was winning, it was tolerable. Once the losses piled up, tolerance disappeared.
FIU made its choice, Cristobal made the most of it, and the rest is college football history.
3. Allan Travers and the Worst Game Score Ever Recorded
This story begins in May of 1912, in a game between the Detroit Tigers and the New York Yankees.
After being heckled by a fan, Ty Cobb charged into the stands and assaulted him. The incident triggered a chain reaction that feels impossible by modern standards.
Ban Johnson, the president of the American League, suspended Cobb indefinitely. In response, the rest of the Tigers voted to strike. Johnson, furious, threatened massive fines if games were not played.
Detroit had no choice. For their next game against the Philadelphia Athletics, Tigers officials scoured North Philadelphia and recruited eight replacement players from the neighborhood. To fill out the roster, three members of the coaching staff, all in their 40s, also suited up.
The result was predictable.
The Athletics won 24–2.
The most unfortunate figure that day was the Tigers’ starting pitcher, Allan Travers. Travers was 20 years old. He had never pitched before. He had failed to make his collegiate baseball team. And now he was on the mound against the defending World Series champions.
Travers pitched a complete game. He allowed 23 earned runs, 26 hits, and seven walks.
Sabermetrician Bill James later developed Game Score to quantify pitching performances. Allan Travers recorded the lowest Game Score ever: minus 70.
In a single game, Travers generated minus 0.4 WAR. Extrapolated over a full season, that pace would land at minus 14 WAR, a number so absurd it almost feels theoretical.
Travers finished his MLB career with a 15.75 ERA and a 22 ERA+. He would later become a Catholic priest.
The replacement players confirmed the day’s strangeness. One later became involved in the Black Sox scandal as a middleman. Another was killed within five years after being thrown through a window during a bar fight. One man, who wore Ty Cobb’s uniform in center field that day, was reportedly struck with a skillet by his wife for daring to replace the legend.
And one of the Tigers’ coaches who played that day became the last MLB player born during the Civil War to appear in a game.
Eventually, Cobb returned. The strike ended. Baseball moved on.
And the romance and mythicism of America’s pastime only kept growing.
We hope you enjoyed this small peek behind the curtain. Fringe ideas don’t always become Fringe articles. But sometimes, even the ones that don’t quite get there still deserve to be told.
If this was your kind of read, you’ll like what’s next. Get The Sandman Ticket, our free, weekly newsletter with picks, insights, and a little bit of everything we love about sports.
